How to Choose the Right Crib Mattress: A New Parent’s Guide to Our Moonlight Slumber Mattresses

If you're designing a dream nursery, don’t overlook one of the most important (and most underrated) pieces: the crib mattress. Sure, the crib gets all the visual attention—but the mattress? That’s where your baby will spend up to 16 hours a day, every day.

At Galt Toys + Galt Baby, we proudly carry the trusted line of Moonlight Slumber crib mattresses, including:

  • Little Dreamer

  • Chill

  • Air

  • Luxury Dreamer

  • Starlight

In this guide, we’ll cover:

  • Why your baby’s mattress matters more than you might think

  • A comparison of our top Moonlight Slumber models

  • Smart tips for testing crib mattresses in-store

Why the Right Crib Mattress Matters

We get it—choosing a crib mattress isn’t exactly glamorous. But it’s one of the most important sleep investments you’ll make in your baby’s first year (and beyond).

Here’s why a good crib mattress is non-negotiable:

  • Safety: A firm, breathable sleep surface helps reduce the risk of SIDS.

  • Development: Proper support is essential for spinal alignment and physical growth.

  • Health: Waterproof and hypoallergenic materials protect against mold, allergens, and leaks.

  • Longevity: A dual-firmness mattress can grow with your baby through the toddler years.

Bottom line? A quality crib mattress = better, safer sleep for everyone.

Comparing Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattresses

Let’s break down the Moonlight Slumber mattresses we carry so you can find the perfect match for your baby (and your budget).

Little Dreamer

A popular choice for a reason.
The Little Dreamer is Moonlight Slumber’s most popular model—and a favorite for parents who want safe, simple, and reliable. It features dual-firmness (a firmer side for infants and a softer side for toddlers), a medical-grade waterproof cover, and hypoallergenic foam. It's lightweight, easy to clean, and built to last through toddlerhood.

Perfect for: Everyday use, budget-conscious families, baby registries.

Chill

Cooler sleep, happier baby.
If your baby tends to get warm while sleeping, the Chill might be the way to go. It features a layer of gel-infused memory foam to help regulate temperature, making it a great option for warmer climates or nurseries. It also has dual-firmness, so it grows with your baby.

Perfect for: Babies who run warm or need temperature-regulated sleep.

Air

The breathable, washable wonder.
The Moonlight Slumber Air is a game-changer for breathability. With a 3D mesh core instead of foam, this mattress is entirely breathable and washable—yes, even the inside. It’s latex-free, hypoallergenic, and ideal for parents looking for peace of mind and ultra-hygienic sleep surfaces.

Perfect for: Safety-conscious parents who prioritize airflow and cleanability.

Luxury Dreamer

A little extra plush without sacrificing support.
The Luxury Dreamer takes everything parents love about the Little Dreamer and levels it up with softer materials, a more luxurious feel, and premium temperature control. It’s still dual-sided and waterproof, but with more cushion on the toddler side.

Perfect for: Parents who want a more cushioned feel while keeping safety front and center.

Starlight

The premium pick with all the bells and whistles.
Starlight is the most feature-rich Moonlight Slumber mattress we carry. It offers reinforced edges (ideal for toddlers who are learning to stand), an antimicrobial, waterproof, and stain-resistant cover, and top-of-the-line dual-firmness comfort.

Perfect for: Families wanting top-tier quality, safety, and durability that lasts through multiple kids.

What to Look for When Shopping In-Store

Seeing and feeling a mattress in person is a great way to compare features. Here’s what to do when you stop by Galt Toys + Galt Baby in Northbrook:

✔️ Test Firmness

Press down on the center and edges. Infant sides should feel firm and supportive, while toddler sides may be slightly softer. All Moonlight Slumber mattresses are designed with dual-firmness in mind.

✔️ Feel the Cover

A good mattress cover should feel soft but durable—not plasticky or crunchy. Moonlight Slumber covers are waterproof, breathable, and made with stretch-knit medical-grade fabric that’s easy to wipe down.

✔️ Smell the Materials

No mattress should have a chemical smell. All Moonlight Slumber mattresses use CertiPUR-US® certified foam, meaning no harmful VOCs, phthalates, or flame-retardant chemicals.

✔️ Ask to Compare

Not sure if the Chill is cooler than the Luxury Dreamer? Want to feel the breathability of the Air vs. the plushness of the Starlight? Our team is here to help you compare side-by-side.

Visit Us In-Store or Shop Online

Want to see the difference for yourself? Come test our Moonlight Slumber collection in-store at Galt Toys + Galt Baby in Northbrook, or shop online anytime.

🛒 Browse Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattresses → Our Mattresses We Offer
🛍️ In-store experts ready to help you find the right fit!

Back to Galt Baby Blogs